
We love sticky toffee pudding, don’t we? And we love cake too. So, here’s my combination of these two much loved sweethearts. Before we get started though, I’ll have to admit that this is a recipe that developed along the way. I’ll explain as we go.



Makes: A moderate sized cake, giving 10 – 12 “rich and hearty” slices
Time: Cake prep: 35 – 40 minutes. Baking: 25 – 30 minutes. Filling, topping and assembly: 40 – 45 minutes. Plus cooling/fridge time
Level: Not difficult
Need: An electric mixer (either hand held or stand), 2 x 20cm round cake tins, preferably with “loose bottoms” (no jokes, please!) Also useful: a cake turntable.





Cake ingredients
- 275g Pitted dates, roughly chopped
- 225ml Hot black tea
- 1 slightly heaped tsp Bicarbonate of soda
- 130g Unsalted butter, softened at room temperature
- 175g Dark muscovado or soft dark brown
- 25g Black treacle or golden syrup
- 3 eggs
- 225g Self-raising flour, sifted (or 55g wholemeal flour + 170g white S.R. flour)
- Pinch of salt.
Ingredients for Toffee Sauce and Buttercream
- 190g Unsalted butter (60g for toffee sauce; 130g softened for the icing).
- 125g Dark brown or Muscovado sugar
- 125ml Double cream (US – heavy cream)
- 225g Icing sugar, sifted (US – confectioner’s sugar)
- Other “on-the-hoof” optional additions (Ricotta & White chocolate – see 6b, below for explanation.)
Method
Prep: Grease and line the bases of the two cake tins
1. Place the chopped dates and hot tea in a saucepan over medium heat for 3–4 minutes until soft. Remove from the heat, stir in the bicarbonate of soda and leave to cool for about 15 minutes. Mash lightly with a fork or blitz briefly for a smoother sponge texture.
2. Heat oven to 160°C fan.
3. Beat the 130g softened butter, 175g Muscovado sugar, and 25g treacle together until pale and fluffy. Beat in the eggs one at a time, adding 10g flour each time to prevent curdling. Fold in the remaining flour and salt, then gently stir in the cooled date mixture until just combined.
4. Divide evenly between the two tins and bake for 25–30 min until a skewer comes out clean. (check at 25 min) Leave to cool in the tins for 10 min before turning out onto a wire rack.
5. For the toffee sauce and buttercream, gently melt 60g butter, 125g dark brown sugar, and 125ml double cream in a pan, simmering for 3–4 minutes until smooth and thickened. Leave to cool completely.
6. Beat the remaining 130g softened butter with the 225g icing sugar until light and airy. Beat in up to a half of the cooled toffee sauce until silky.
6b. I like to leave buttercream in the fridge for a while to firm up before using. On this occasion, when I tasted it I thought it was oversweet. But what could I do? Aha, I had a tub of Ricotta in the fridge, so a quick “on-the-hoof” adaptation took place. I mixed them: 2 parts original buttercream to one part Ricotta. It was smoother and plenty sweet enough, but it was now too runny. So, second “on-the-hoof” adaptation: I melted 100g of white chocolate and mixed it in. Wow, what a good result. Smoother and tastier and there was more of it.



7. Place the first cooled sponge on a plate, spread over half of the toffee buttercream, and top with the second sponge.
8. Swirl the remaining buttercream on top and drizzle over the leftover toffee sauce so it drips down the sides.
8a. Alternatively, you can use less toffee sauce on the cake and reserve some to pour over later, warmed.

If you’d like to make a larger version, here are the measurements for a 23cm version:
Ingredients for two 23cm sponges
- 350g pitted dates, roughly chopped.
- 300ml hot black tea
- 1½ tsp bicarbonate of soda.
- 175g unsalted butter. softened at room temperature.
- 225g dark muscovado or soft dark brown sugar
- 30g black treacle or golden syrup
- 3 eggs
- 300g self-raising flour, sifted (can use 75g Wholemeal + 225g white)
- ½ tsp Fine salt
For the Toffee sauce and buttercream
- 250g unsalted butter (75g for the sauce, 175g softened for the icing).
- 150g dark brown or muscovado sugar
- 150ml double cream
- 300g Icing sugar, sifted.
NB If you want to be extra indulgent with lots of filling and toffee sauce for your 20cm version, use the above sauce and buttercream measurements, I did.
I hope you enjoy this lovely cake. If you want more cake recipes click this link, or have a look at my site for lots of other great recipes. Below are a few that I’d love you to try:
Cherry, Almond & Chocolate Cake












Honey Pistachio and Ginger Cheesecake



To make a comment or ask a question please go to the contact page. Click here for the home page.